Clay Soil
headerphoto


Clay Soil

by Doug
(in the garden)

Clay Soil


When we're talking about improving our clay soil gardens, there's one thing we have to understand first. And that is how soils are structured.

Soil Structure Does Not Equal Soil Fertility



The soil structure is the basic underlying mineral component of our soil, the parent material that includes ground up minerals - sand, silt and clay.

Organic matter is also a minor part (in terms of percentage of material) of the soil structure and we’ll talk about this in more depth later.


A minor point but an interesting one is that your top soil isn’t necessarily connected to your underlying rock material. For example, the top soil in the Mid-west is often composed of soil that was blown in (called loess). Soil can accumulate in different regions in different ways (including clay soil) but this isn’t the subject of this session. :-)

Sand



Sand particles are the 600-pound gorillas of the soil world. These are big guys (measuring .05 to 2 mm in size)

When we have a sandy soil, the big particles fit together with a lot of air spaces between them.

This allows several things to happen: water moves down through the sand quickly so drainage is fast and excellent (too excellent in sandy soils). Soil fertility also tends to be poor because the water tends to remove the fertilizer salts in it’s rapid downward progression.

Oxygen content is high and the space between particles is large; this lends itself to great root development but also high O2 levels can lead
to rapid consumption of organic matter.

So sand comes with the advantages of great drainage but poor fertility and water holding capacity. You can grow a good garden in a sandy soil but you have to apply a lot of water to do so.

Silt



Silt particles are the intermediate sized particles in the mix. They are .0002 to .05 mm in size.

They fit together a little tighter than sand so the drainage is not as good but water holding capacity is better. Air spaces aren’t as large
so root development isn’t as fast but between the water and the lack of available O2, fertility levels are higher than sand.

Silt soils are typically very productive garden soils.

Clay



Clay soil particles are tiny, measuring less than .0002 mm in size.

They pack together very tightly, water tends not to run out and drainage is poor.

Oxygen content is low and small roots have a tough time working their way through between the open areas.

On the other hand, fertility is good because the nutrients have nowhere to go.

Clay soil presents more gardening problems than the other two types because they are harder to fix.


Practical Garden Soils




Soils are a mix of all three components and the proportion of sand to silt to clay determines what kind of soil you have.

The higher the proportion of clay in the mix, the worse your garden soil is going to be.

Generally, when clay starts to rise above the 30 percent mark, we start noticing it.

When it rises over the 40 percent mark, we know we have clay and over 50 percent, we don’t have clay - we have trouble.

At 60 percent clay, we have pottery (give or take a bit)


So What’s This Mean?



Practically speaking for the home gardener, it depends. If you have a slight clay problem, you can amend it and make it a very fertile soil.
Or, you can handle the problems by cultivating and managing the soil properly.

If you have a serious clay problem, then we’re looking at some other serious solutions. And those will be dealt with in the next few posts.

What is important in this post about your clay soil is that you understand exactly what you're dealing with before you launch yourself into some form of garden-torture.

Comments for
Clay Soil

Click here to add your own comments

a man with muscle is the answer
by: elaine

I've lived with really heavy clay for 22 long hard years and finally given up - least my back has.I brought a man with mucsle in and he has landscaped for me and done a wonderful job - lots of gravel, raised beds and managable borders.Roll on next summer :) elaine (uk )

Sugar Clay soil
by: GLB

We have sugar clay here in NW Missouri and believe me we have tried to amend soil etc and still have problems.
I was use to black soil that you could grow anything in and since our move 3 years ago it is disheartening to try to grow anything.
Asking for suggestions ???????

annuals for clay
by: Anonymous

I have found that my western Montana clay soils respond well to annuals like nusturtiums (sp?) and various wildflowers...someone was asking what annuals do well in clay.

CLAY SOIL
by: Debbiedoo

Moved to Mississippi from Long Island New York......I totally miss LI soil. I had some beautiful flower gardens which was so easy to start and maintain. I am determined to get and keep my love of flowers, but it is hard work here. Now I know why not many people here have much in the way of flower gardens. Good luck to all and use plenty of top soil and mulch. Clay sucks!

Clay Soil
by: Debbie F.

Having lived with clay soil for 21+ years,
I find the best advice is to simply build your beds up. My clay is like concrete. Very difficult.
My beds that I have built up with topsoil and peat etc. do well.

annuals
by: jackie

does anyone have any suggestions for annuals for clay soil? The ones I've tried haven't done too well.

Knightdale, NC
by: Carol

I would like to offer some thoughts on clay soils. My yard has lots of clay - some of it under a layer of sand. I bought my property 16 years ago. When I started planting, it took a major effort to dig a hole. I found my favorite hand tool was the "garden claw". Much of the area I wanted to grow flowers in had been off-street parking - so it was heavily compacted. Other areas near the driveway had also been used for parking and had lots of large gravel added - and was, as you might expect, also heavily compacted.

I began improving my soil by using lots of leaf mulch (which I got free for some time) from the county-run recycling program. (I pay a modest amount for it now.) In addition to the leaf mulch, I used newspapers. I would lay down a thick layer of newspaper, and cover it with about 4 inches of leaf mulch. I then added more mulch over the years until the soil softened and began to turn black. I now have a border by the street with plants that take only moments to plant. I dig with a trowel now instead of the claw.

Last year I retired. I decided to convert my front "lawn" into garden and paths. Most of my grass is what we call "wire" grass. It spreads by runners and is difficult to kill. It is not a very pretty sight. I again turned to my old standby... newspapers and mulch. I found a company cutting down some trees in my neighborhood. They happily delivered about 10 cubic yards of chipped leaves/branches, which I used on top of newspapers to create paths around the yard. Another person had some excess riprap (big chunks of stone which is often used to control runoff) which I could have just for hauling it away. I used this to line the paths and, after speaking with my neighbor to get his approval, to edge the yard.

I found a recipe for "moss" which gives the stones an aged, "been there forever" look which I'm planning to apply soon. It "dresses" up the stones a bit. I get/share plants with other gardeners. I buy plants from stores when they go for half price because they are bloomed out, or whatever. I focus my efforts on perennials as they are the best buy in the long run. I do buy a few annuals in the spring for color.

People now slow down as they drive past our house. They stop sometimes and tell me how much they enjoy my garden. It is far from my dream - but it is coming along nicely. Last summer we added a 15x20' Koi pond and a 12x30'deck overhanging it. We spend many summer hours there, enjoying the tranquility of our front yard. I have a plaque on my front door saying "One is nearer God's heart in a garden than anywhere else on earth." I must agree... whether planting or weeding... or just sitting and looking... I love being in my little garden.

The point I'm really trying to make is that I'm not young, nor rich. The tools I use are inexpensive or free. With patience and persistence, I'm converting my horrid clay soil into a rich, friable loam.

even more fun
by: Anonymous

my backyard is not only a thin layer of topsoil over hard red clay, but also above the watertable most of the time; so when you dig a hole, even if you don't put water in it, it's full the next day. so it's all willows and swamp azaleas for me. at least i don't worry too much about drought back there.

pond digging in clay
by: Marie

Wow- I am totally in a clay zone! I'm in Cambridge, Ont. We dug our pond and I could literally mold the shape of it like pure clay. No cave- ins was a real bonus, and laying down the liner was a breeze. It does suck to grow veggies though. I amend every year, and I always get poor crop yields. Even my clematis is growing poorly now. Guess I have been lax in keeping up with exactly HOW MUCH I need to add to my soil. I get lazy some years- and poorer, so I tend to cut back on the expensive soil truck-ins as of the last few years. I am serious about a total food garden and wiping out all the flowers(most of them) as we are involved in a community food co-op now. Sounds like a positive step in this nasty financial climate we are now living in. So, I DO NEED my soil to work for me, and count! High yields are paramount for me for the first time in my 10 years working this soil.

clay
by: Susan

I live in North Texas, and we have horrible clay. We tried to break it up with a tiller, and spent the afternoon digging clay out of the tines with screwdrivers and putty knives. We are doing lasagna gardening now. It's much easier, and so far, working out well.

Slope of clay
by: Anonymous

We have a slope in our backyard that is really hard to dig in. I put water in the hole to make it easier to dig the next day and the water is still in the hole. Is that clay soil and how do I get rid of it on a slope? When will this topic continue?
Thanks

Clay Soil
by: Dorothy

I have gardened in the same clay soil for over 40 years now. Every few years, I add triple mix and every second year, lots of mulch. The soil is much better now, but the clay is still there, about a foot down. Don't think you can ever get rid of this stuff as clay keeps moving and seems to work its way back up again.

evaluating clay soil
by: marilyn

your descriptions were clear. Hardpan is obvious and practically impemeable. Is it important to measure the % of clay otherwise and if so how?

wondering about red clay
by: Goodie

We built a 3 foot wall to accomodate a labyrinth I want to build. We got free fill dirt from a nearby building site that was red clay...similar to other areas in my yard since it was down the street. I figured I could amend the areas where I wanted to plant shrubs and perennials. My question is, this red clay seems to bread apart nicely and isn't at all like some of the really hard clay I've dug into in other areas. Will this also harden later or is it OK to plant in as is?

oops
by: Suzy

My last comment said it was from annonymous, because I neglected to click in my name again.

Serious clay problem
by: Judy

After reading Doug's soil descriptions, I've learned my soil has a serious clay problem. We actually cannot dig a hole deeper than about 4 inches using a spade shovel. Our neighbors describe the soil around here as 'clay and iron ore' (I'm in Louisiana). Not sure what the iron ore is unless it's the clay-colored rocks we dig up. When we roto till, we have run into clay so thick we can mold it into shapes. It's no wonder our neighbors just have mulch delivered and poured on top of their soil in order to make flower beds. But I would still like to improve my soil, if that's possible.

Amending clay soil
by: Kathy M

I live in Windsor, ON. The soil is clay here. When we first moved into this house, I had a real hard time. Then I learned about compost. My husband made me one. It took many yrs. of adding compost to the soil, in spring, and late fall.
Now I have great soil. I even used the mulched leaves in the fall, and put that over the fresh compost...it works, if your willing to make the soil better.

depth of clay
by: Anonymous

It gets more clay-ey the deeper you go. Just a spade-depth or 2 and it's almost impossible to penetrate, as I remember.

Layers
by: Margi

You didn't mention anything about the proportion of clay at different levels. I have pottery at varying depths.

clay soil, compost, and critters
by: Suzy

My soil is clay and after 12 years of working the beds, most of my veggies are still small. I use my own compost as well as chicken- and cow-stall stuff when I can get it. I like the Ruth Stout method but - the big question - how to deal with rats? I can't put the compost from my kitchen directly onto the beds because we have rats (in the country there's always rats in winter, after they harvest the surrounding fields). I did try digging it down as Doug suggested until the ground froze, and when planting season starts in a month or 2 (I live in Denmark) I will see how the soil looks there. Otherwise, I have added sand, I dig the beds every year.....last year I had luck with Brussels sprouts for the 1st time, so maybe it's getting better, slowly. I gave up trying to grow carrots. Even my kale was lousy last year, which is supposed to be so easy to grow.

We have a no drainage area
by: Dennis

In from of our house is a sidewalk and beyond the sidewalk is a 4 foot wide strip of "dirt", then a curb and the street. The "dirt is clay! When it rains this areas fills up with water and runs over the curb into the street. Water remains visible for about two days. This near impervious soil is at least 18" deep. As we live on a corner, ther is about 100 feet of this that would be nice to have available for gardening.

Click here to add your own comments









Doug's Facebook Page